Information
Version: C | 1.1 (2024-12-31)
- minor editorial changes plus new side note "Commercial relevance"
WelfareScore | farm
Condensed assessment of the species' likelihood and potential for good fish welfare in aquaculture, based on ethological findings for 10 crucial criteria.
- Li = Likelihood that the individuals of the species experience good welfare under minimal farming conditions
- Po = Potential of the individuals of the species to experience good welfare under high-standard farming conditions
- Ce = Certainty of our findings in Likelihood and Potential
WelfareScore = Sum of criteria scoring "High" (max. 10)
General remarks
Cirrhinus molitorella is a freshwater cyprinid fish that naturally inhabits Asia waters at Mekong, Chao Phraya, Nam Theun, Xe Bangfai, the Nanpangjiang basins and also from the Red River in China and Viet Nam and Pearl River in China. It is found from midwater to bottom depths of lakes, reservoirs, and large and medium-sized rivers, occurring in rapids and slow deep reaches, thus preferring flowing water. This cyprinid makes a low mating call, with many bubbles coming up to the water surface when breeding. Because of anthropogenic disturbances such as the construction of dams, overfishing, and water pollution, the abundance and distribution range of this carp has declined. C. molitorella began to be cultured much later than Cyprinus carpio. It has been introduced to several countries, including Indonesia, Singapore, Japan, Taiwan Province of China, and Hong Kong SAR.
Although this species grows slowly and does not reach a large size as other carps and although it is difficult to harvest without draining, there are some advantages to rearing it: It can be reared in high density, its production rate is high, and it has good meat quality and high nutritional value, making it one of the most important species cultured in inland water bodies in southern China. Important wild information about depth range, migratory behaviours, and especially about home range and aggregation patterns of this cyprinid is still missing. Moreover, farming information about substrate availability and aggression is limited, and information about stress and malformations is missing so far. Further research taking this into account is needed to better assess and improve the welfare of C. molitorella in farms.
1 Home range
Many species traverse in a limited horizontal space (even if just for a certain period of time per year); the home range may be described as a species' understanding of its environment (i.e., its cognitive map) for the most important resources it needs access to.
What is the probability of providing the species' whole home range in captivity?
It is unclear for minimal and high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a low amount of evidence.2 Depth range
Given the availability of resources (food, shelter) or the need to avoid predators, species spend their time within a certain depth range.
What is the probability of providing the species' whole depth range in captivity?
It is low for minimal farming conditions. It is medium for high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a medium amount of evidence.3 Migration
Some species undergo seasonal changes of environments for different purposes (feeding, spawning, etc.), and to move there, they migrate for more or less extensive distances.
What is the probability of providing farming conditions that are compatible with the migrating or habitat-changing behaviour of the species?
It is high for minimal and high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a low amount of evidence.4 Reproduction
A species reproduces at a certain age, season, and sex ratio and possibly involving courtship rituals.
What is the probability of the species reproducing naturally in captivity without manipulation of these circumstances?
It is low for minimal and high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a medium amount of evidence.5 Aggregation
Species differ in the way they co-exist with conspecifics or other species from being solitary to aggregating unstructured, casually roaming in shoals or closely coordinating in schools of varying densities.
What is the probability of providing farming conditions that are compatible with the aggregation behaviour of the species?
It is unclear for minimal and high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a low amount of evidence.6 Aggression
There is a range of adverse reactions in species, spanning from being relatively indifferent towards others to defending valuable resources (e.g., food, territory, mates) to actively attacking opponents.
What is the probability of the species being non-aggressive and non-territorial in captivity?
It is low for minimal farming conditions. It is medium for high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a low amount of evidence.7 Substrate
Depending on where in the water column the species lives, it differs in interacting with or relying on various substrates for feeding or covering purposes (e.g., plants, rocks and stones, sand and mud, turbidity).
What is the probability of providing the species' substrate and shelter needs in captivity?
It is low for minimal farming conditions. It is medium for high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a medium amount of evidence.8 Stress
Farming involves subjecting the species to diverse procedures (e.g., handling, air exposure, short-term confinement, short-term crowding, transport), sudden parameter changes or repeated disturbances (e.g., husbandry, size-grading).
What is the probability of the species not being stressed?
There are no findings for minimal and high-standard farming conditions.9 Malformations
Deformities that – in contrast to diseases – are commonly irreversible may indicate sub-optimal rearing conditions (e.g., mechanical stress during hatching and rearing, environmental factors unless mentioned in crit. 3, aquatic pollutants, nutritional deficiencies) or a general incompatibility of the species with being farmed.
What is the probability of the species being malformed rarely?
It is unclear for minimal and high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a low amount of evidence.10 Slaughter
The cornerstone for a humane treatment is that slaughter a) immediately follows stunning (i.e., while the individual is unconscious), b) happens according to a clear and reproducible set of instructions verified under farming conditions, and c) avoids pain, suffering, and distress.
What is the probability of the species being slaughtered according to a humane slaughter protocol?
It is low for minimal farming conditions. It is medium for high-standard farming conditions. Our conclusion is based on a low amount of evidence.Side note: Domestication
Teletchea and Fontaine introduced 5 domestication levels illustrating how far species are from having their life cycle closed in captivity without wild input, how long they have been reared in captivity, and whether breeding programmes are in place.
What is the species’ domestication level?
DOMESTICATION LEVEL 433, level 5 being fully domesticated.
Side note: Forage fish in the feed
450-1,000 milliard wild-caught fishes end up being processed into fish meal and fish oil each year which contributes to overfishing and represents enormous suffering. There is a broad range of feeding types within species reared in captivity.
To what degree may fish meal and fish oil based on forage fish be replaced by non-forage fishery components (e.g., poultry blood meal) or sustainable sources (e.g., soybean cake)?
All age classes:
- WILD: omnivorous 2441148, detritivorous 164 (LARVAE and FRY feed on zooplankton 4), ilyophagous 10.
- FARM: as a major species in polycultures at growout stage: hardly any use of fish meal or other animal protein in the feed (<10%), fertilisation can reduce the quantity of feed needed by enhancing natural food availability 4; as a secondary species in polycultures at growout stage: no special feeding required 4. Food wastes mainly containing cereal or cereal and meat meal, with lower fish meal percentage (10%), can replace commercial feeds 714.
- LAB: no data found yet.
*partly = <51% – mostly = 51-99% – completely = 100%
Side note: Commercial relevance
How much is this species farmed annually?
Estimated 4,515 t in 2022 34.
Glossary
BENTHOPELAGIC = living and feeding near the bottom of a body of water, floating above the floor
DOMESTICATION LEVEL 4 = entire life cycle closed in captivity without wild inputs 33
FARM = setting in farming environment or under conditions simulating farming environment in terms of size of facility or number of individuals
FRY = larvae from external feeding on
IND = individuals
JUVENILES = fully developed but immature individuals
LAB = setting in laboratory environment
LARVAE = hatching to mouth opening
PHOTOPERIOD = duration of daylight
POTAMODROMOUS = migrating within fresh water
SPAWNERS = adults during the spawning season; in farms: adults that are kept as broodstock
WILD = setting in the wild
Bibliography
2 Nuanthavong, Tick, and La Vilayphone. 2005. Reproduction and nursing of Cirrhinus molitorella in a small fish farm in Luang Prabang Province, Lao PDR: 7.
3 Lasasimma, O., and B. A. Ingram. 2008. Production of Cirrhinus molitorella and Labeo chrysophekadion for culture based fisheries development in Lao PDR 2: Nursery culture and grow-out. Aquaculture Asia Magazine.
4 Xinping, Z. 2009. Cultured Aquatic Species Information Programme. Cirrhinus molitorella. Rome: FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Department.
5 Jhingran, V.G., and R.S.V. Pullin. 1985. A hatchery manual for the common, Chinese and Indian major carps. Vol. 252. ICLARM Studies and Reviews 11. Asian Development Bank and International Center for Living Aquatic Resources Management.
6 Cheng, Z., W. Y. Mo, Y. B. Man, C. L. Lam, W. M. Choi, X. P. Nie, Y. H. Liu, and M. H. Wong. 2015. Environmental mercury concentrations in cultured low-trophic-level fish using food waste-based diets. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 22: 495–507. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-014-3333-6.
7 Mo, W. Y., Z. Cheng, W. M. Choi, Y. B. Man, Y. Liu, and M. H. Wong. 2014. Application of food waste based diets in polyculture of low trophic level fish: Effects on fish growth, water quality and plankton density. Marine Pollution Bulletin 85: 803–809. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2014.01.020.
8 Aiguo, Z., S. Di, W. Chong, C. Yuliang, X. Shaolin, L. Peiqin, X. Guohuan, T. Huijuan, and Z. Jixing. 2022. Characteristics and differences of microplastics ingestion for farmed fish with different water depths, feeding habits and diets. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering 10: 107189. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jece.2022.107189.
9 Lv, M., H. Gan, Z. Ruan, H. Yang, R. Wang, L. Shafique, H. Naz, and H. Ma. 2020. Distributions of and Correlations between Cd, Cr, and Hg Concentrations in Suspended Particles and Sediment in Aquaculture Ponds and in Cirrhinus molitorella Tissues. Pakistan Journal of Zoology 52: 1735–1743. https://doi.org/10.17582/journal.pjz/20190317200334.
10 Bowen, S. H., B. Gu, and Z. Huang. 2006. Diet and Digestion in Chinese Mud Carp Cirrhinus molitorella Compared with Other Ilyophagous Fishes. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 135: 1383–1388. https://doi.org/10.1577/T05-158.1.
11 Fisheries Research Institute of the Kwangs Chuang Autonomous Region. 1975. On the biology and culture of the mud carp, Cirrhinus molitorella. Acta Hydrobiologica Sinica 5: 450–468.
12 Huang, Y., X. Li, S. Zhu, and Z. Wu. 2018. Identification of two hatch date-dependent cohorts and variation in early growth rate of mud carp (Cirrhinus molitorella) in the Pearl River Delta, China. Marine and Freshwater Research 69: 1231–1237. https://doi.org/10.1071/MF17278.
13 Lu, K. 1990. Fishery Resources Investigation in the Pearl River. Guangzhou, China: Guangdong Province Science Publication.
14 Cheng, Z., W.-Y. Mo, C.-L. Lam, W.-M. Choi, and M.-H. Wong. 2015. Replacing fish meal by food waste to produce lower trophic level fish containing acceptable levels of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: Health risk assessments. The Science of the Total Environment 523: 253–261. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.04.016.
15 Froese, R., and D. Pauly. 2022. Mud carp (Cirrhinus molitorella): fisheries, aquaculture, aquarium. World Wide Web electronic publication. FishBase.
16 Shao, K. T., and P. L. Lim. 1991. Fishes of freshwater and estuary. Encyclopedia of field guide in Taiwan. Vol. 31. Taipei, Taiwan: Recreation Press, Co., Ltd.,.
17 Roberts, T. R. 1997. Systematic revision of the tropical Asian labeon cyprinid fish genus Cirrhinus, with descriptions of new species and biological observations on C. lobatus. Nat. Hist. Bull. Siam Soc. 45: 171–203.
18 Sun, R., X. Luo, X. Zheng, K. Cao, P. Peng, Q. X. Li, and B. Mai. 2018. Hexabromocyclododecanes (HBCDs) in fish: Evidence of recent HBCD input into the coastal environment. Marine Pollution Bulletin 126: 357–362. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2017.11.040.
19 Yu, F. D., D. E. Gu, Y. N. Tong, G. J. Li, H. Wei, X. D. Mu, M. Xu, et al. 2019. The current distribution of invasive mrigal carp ( Cirrhinus mrigala ) in Southern China, and its potential impacts on native mud carp ( Cirrhinus molitorella ) populations. Journal of Freshwater Ecology 34: 603–616. https://doi.org/10.1080/02705060.2019.1655492.
20 Xian, H., M. Tang, Y. Chen, Z. Lian, Y. Li, X. Peng, and D. Hu. 2021. Indigenous Fish-Based Assessment of Genotoxic Potentials of the Helong Reservoir in Guangzhou, China. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 40: 1919–1925. https://doi.org/10.1002/etc.5043.
21 Xie, Y., K. S. T.. Kanankege, Z. Jiang, S. Liu, Y. Yang, X. Wan, and A. M. Perez. 2022. Epidemiological characterization of Clonorchis sinensis infection in humans and freshwater fish in Guangxi, China. BMC Infectious Diseases 22: 263. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12879-022-07244-2.
22 Baensch, H. A., and R. Riehl. 1991. Aquarien Atlas, Band 3. Melle, Germany: Mergus Verlag.
23 Tan, X., X. Li, S. Lek, Y. Li, C. Wang, J. Li, and J. Luo. 2010. Annual dynamics of the abundance of fish larvae and its relationship with hydrological variation in the Pearl River. Environmental Biology of Fishes 88: 217–225. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-010-9632-y.
24 Lim, P., S. Lek, S. T. Touch, S.-O. Mao, and B. Chhouk. 1999. Diversity and spatial distribution of freshwater fish in Great Lake and Tonle Sap river (Cambodia, Southeast Asia). Aquatic Living Resources 12: 379–386. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0990-7440(99)00107-2.
25 Gorda, S. 2001. Fish Propagation and Nursing Techniques. LARReC Research Report 0012. Vientiane, Laos.
26 Ingram, B. A., and O. Lasasimma. 2008. Production of Cirrhinus molitorella and Labeo chrysophekadion for culture based fi sheries development in Lao PDR Part I: Captive spawning. Aquaculture Asia Magazine.
27 Shuai, F., X. Li, Y. Li, J. Li, J. Yang, and S. Lek. 2016. Temporal Patterns of Larval Fish Occurrence in a Large Subtropical River. PLOS ONE 11: e0146441. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0146441.
28 Morioka, S. M., B. Vongvichith, P. Chanthasone, and P. Phommachan. 2021. Developmental morphology and growth in early stages of laboratory-reared Cirrhinus molitorella and C. microlepis (Cypriniformes: Cyprinidae). Ichthyological Research 68: 506–516. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10228-021-00803-8.
29 Somboon, S. O., S. P. Amphone, L. Khamsivilay, and B. Saphakdy. 2003. Nursing Cirrhinus molitorella in the earthen ponds with four different stocking densities. In Proceedings of the Fifth Technical Symposium on Mekong Fisheries, 11-12 December 2002, 155–158. Poulsen, A. (Mekong River Commission Phnom Penh).
30 European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). 2009. Species-specific welfare aspects of the main systems of stunning and killing of farmed Carp. EFSA Journal 1013: 1–37. https://doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2009.1013.
31 Rahmanifarah, K., B. Shabanpour, and A. Sattari. 2011. Effects of Clove Oil on Behavior and Flesh Quality of Common Carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) in Comparison with Pre-slaughter CO2 Stunning, Chilling and Asphyxia. Turkish Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 11: 139–147.
32 Retter, Karina, Karl-Heinz Esser, Matthias Lüpke, John Hellmann, Dieter Steinhagen, and Verena Jung-Schroers. 2018. Stunning of common carp: Results from a field and a laboratory study. BMC Veterinary Research 14: 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12917-018-1530-0.
33 Teletchea, Fabrice, and Pascal Fontaine. 2012. Levels of domestication in fish: implications for the sustainable future of aquaculture. Fish and Fisheries 15: 181–195. https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12006.
34 FAO. 2024. FishStat: Global aquaculture production 1950-2022. www.fao.org/fishery/en/statistics/software/fishstatj: FishStatJ.
